As some of you know, last year, I was alone on Thanksgiving Day. The day turned out to be peaceful. Full of quiet reflection. So, I’ve been reflecting on that day as November started peeking around the corner.
And it occurred to me that we don’t actually have to have the big traditional eat-til-you-explode meal extravaganza any more if we don’t want to. The trouble is that I love to cook Thanksgiving food. And the hubster loves to eat it. (Except neither one of us eats much meat anymore and could do without the turkey.) Plus, not to boast or anything, but my Thanksgiving Feast is, well, okay, I’ll just say it. Epic.
The most important part of the meal are the pies, of course. In case you haven’t heard about the Roving Pie, have a seat. Grab a fork.
I’ve been baking Thanksgiving pies for well over 30 years. Without question, whether the table is full of guests or we are alone, three pies always make an appearance. The Apple Pie. The Pumpkin Pie. And the Pecan Pie. (These pies are so important, each warrant a separate sentence.) The Apple Pie is made with Granny Smith apples only, at least eight cups worth, with brown sugar, cinnamon, and a bit of this and that. The Pumpkin Pie is a version from Southern Living that is so smooth, it just doesn’t warrant any messing with. And the Pecan Pie is devoid of corn syrup, but chock full of whole pecans (about three times more than any recipe would have the nerve to suggest) and a hearty helping of brown sugar. All are paired with an all-butter crust. I know you have been told that you need to add shortening to get the right crust flakiness. Or vodka. Or some other nonsense. You don’t. Period. King Arthur all-purpose flour, unsalted butter, a swig of salt, and 4 tablespoons of iced water. That’s it. And, just try to say my crusts are not flaky.
But those are only three pies. I always make at least four. The fourth pie is the Roving Pie. The Roving Pie emerged decades ago when I decided to “try something new.” For whatever reason, I chose to make a pie I had never made before. And to make it even more interesting, I decided that I would never make it again. No matter what. This quickly became a Pardun Tradition that has now been passed on to my daughter Grace. I am pleased to report that she takes her role as Keeper of the Roving Pie Tradition very seriously. As she should.
Most of these Thanksgiving pies have turned out rather stellar. But a couple have been bloopers. I seem to remember the pear/cranberry/walnut concoction not going over well. But, the coconut cream macadamia nut was a huge hit one year, as was the chocolate-lined crusted cream pie. The pineapple grits pie was, um, interesting.
Often a fifth pie would make an appearance. The Decoy Pie. This tradition started when the hubster felt sorry for our new next-door neighbors one year and invited them to Thanksgiving Dinner (which is always at 2:00, no exceptions, by the way. Did I mention I have traditions?). They were happy to come and they also let us know that they would be bringing all their relatives who were flying in to visit. I didn’t know these people, but one thing I did know was that I sure didn’t want them hogging the apple, pumpkin or pecan pies. So, I made a raspberry cream pie that was extremely showy. A piled-high mound of yumminess. And then I talked it up while we were eating. Sure enough! They took the bait, loved the pie and kept their pie-crusty mitts off our beloved traditional pies. Everyone walked away sated–and happy. From that year on, if someone new was at the table, the Decoy Pie would make a showing—and all the “regulars” knew it was their job to convince the “newbies” that the Decoy Pie was the best.
Outside of the pies, the Thanksgiving meal is a typical New England dinner. Turkey, gravy, mashed potatoes, honey glazed carrots, herbed stuffing, balsamic pearl onions, etc., etc., etc.,
Who wouldn’t look forward to a meal like that?
Except, neither of us can eat all that at one sitting any more. Nor do we care to. What to do? What to do?
Introducing Thanksgiving Month. With a renewed sense of “hey, we’re getting older and it is perfectly fine to do things differently if we want to,” we are going to try ignoring Turkey Day this year. But, we’ll still eat all the foods we love. We’ll just take a month to do it.
It’s early November so we have just started this, but so far, it’s been a success. I baked the pecan pie (with maple syrup infused whipped cream) this past weekend. We invited friends over to share it with us. I also made mashed potatoes (spiffed up with crème fraiche) and peas along with baked honey-marinated salmon. Next up, I think we’ll hit the stuffing and the pumpkin pie.
Since having my mid-life crisis (okay, my two-thirds life crisis), I have a new lease on life. There are all sorts of things in life that I love—and no one loves tradition more than me—but I’m discovering that I’m ready to let go of traditions and do things a little bit differently. Which leads me to two other “You Did What?!” things that have happened recently.
First, I sold my boat. It was a tough decision, but the right one. I’m still rowing, but now, I row with one club rather than two, and never alone as I often did in my single. I’ve got to say that I’ve relished the rows I have had since letting go of my boat because I know how fortunate I am to still have a group of people to row with. And, especially a group that still wants to row with me.
Second, I’ve taken the proceeds from my boat sale and booked another cruise for the hubster and me. We’ll be tooling around the Caribbean for two weeks over the university holiday for no reason other than to relax, read, and hang out. Yes, I know we could do that at home, but for whatever reason I felt compelled to trade one boat (albeit one that only weighed 34 pounds) for another boating experience. The hubs asked many, many times “Uh, really? Do you really, really want to do this? Why? Why?” But, in the end, he agreed, trusting me that getting away will be good for us. (And, yes, I do remember that we “got away” for a whole month this past summer.)
I began this blog three years ago in preparation for my sabbatical. I called it My Year Away. I expected the year to be life-changing. And it was. I learned so much that I decided to continue writing the blog, renaming it My Year Away. And Back. I thought I would be done by now. But, once I got Achalasia, I had a whole additional experience about being “away” from normal—and working my way back. Since then, I’ve decided that “Being Away” is a state of mind that I should relish as I try to navigate life in my 60s. That involves doing things differently (like Thanksgiving Month, for example). And, I think it also means spending part of all my remaining years “Away.”
St. Augustine wrote “The world is a book, and those who do not travel read only a page.” I might not make it through the whole book, but it won’t be for lack of trying. Eating Thanksgiving over 30 days. Meandering the Caribbean on a Cruise Ship. Rowing at Sunrise. Now, if I can just finish the semester…
November 8, 2017 at 10:31 pm
Lovely blog post, there Dr. Pardun! Don’t slip too far away from some traditional friends though!
November 9, 2017 at 4:40 am
Great traditions but I agree. When the kids move away, what’s the point? We are going to Carolina Club to eat a buffet with the foreign students who can’t go home. And no dishes to wash!
November 9, 2017 at 7:07 pm
Decoy Pie was my favorite. Very fun-to-read post!
November 10, 2017 at 1:06 pm
LikeLiked by 1 person